Blending ETFs, Stocks at the Sector Level
Kotok notes that he and his team make overweight or underweight decisions for each of the S&P 500 sectors based on "macro inputs" and a "rationale for the decision." Cumberland is overweight health care because he believes all the bad news is priced in and that health care is growing as a portion of GDP. The firm's current exposure in the sector, per the article, consists of the Healthcare Sector SPDR
This is an excellent way to capture the full utility available from the ETF product wrapper. For investors willing and able to devote the time, blending together different exposures within the sector allows for very precise portfolio construction. One step further would be a combination of narrow-based ETFs like Kotok uses and individual stocks.
The advantages in using an ETF/individual stock combination include even more precision as not every segment of the market is represented in an ETF and also the opportunity for higher dividend yields.
For example the Healthcare Sector SPDR has a trailing yield of 1.95% but most of the larger constituents of that fund yield far more than that. Johnson & Johnson
It is reasonable that not every market participant would be comfortable picking stocks in every sector, but increasing the dividend yield of the portfolio is a reason to incorporate at least some individual names.
Another consideration is the use of foreign ETFs and thematic ETFs (which may or may not include foreign stocks). We can see the advantage illustrated in the materials sector. The Basic Materials Sector SPDR
The iShares S&P Global Materials Sector Index Fund
However, while the boom times were been better for the mining-centric MXI, the last 12 months were not so kind as MXI has lagged badly going down 14% compared to just 6% for XLB.
For one final example, let's look at the allocation our firm has for client accounts in the industrial sector. We use a very similar approach as Kotok and Cumberland but include individual stocks. For ETFs in the sector we use the PowerShares Water Portfolio
The other ETF we use is the iShares S&P Emerging Markets Infrastructure Index Fund
While our mix could fare poorly depending on what the market has in store, it obviously captures plenty of foreign and thematic segments within the sector and a dividend yield that is quite a bit higher than XLI.