Caught Holding the Facebook Bag
By Richard Saintvilus - 05/24/12 - 7:59 AM EDT
Tickers in this article: FB
NEW YORK (TheStreet
) -- It never ceases to amaze me to see just how spoiled and childish Wall Street can be sometimes. Complaints are quickly filed and fingers get pointed whenever a seemingly guaranteed instant gratification fails to deliver. My article
Tuesday on social media giant Facebook
was not "liked" by investors who are now left holding the Facebook bag after buying at the top range of an IPO that was once billed as a promising pay day.
In numerous emails, I was called insensitive for my having described retail investors as "unsophisticated and greedy speculators that got what they deserve." Aside from the fact that I was blatantly misquoted in these love-filled notes, I was more disappointed as it seems nothing was learned through this event. Each note suggested it was everyone else's fault except the investor's. However, as I read each one of them and try to put myself in their shoes, fundamentally, I just could not sympathize for what was the result of greed. But it was not because I did not try.
Though I angered some investors in my analysis, disappointingly, I think I was somewhat reserved in my appraisal of the situation. The embarrassment surrounding the stock's plummeting valuation and suspicions that surrounded the failed trade confirmations by Nasdaq have become a significant mess -- one that Wall Street would much rather leave up to someone else to clean up.
What this means is that nothing will likely get done and we can expect something like this to happen again.
With the stock having now closed at $32 and trading at 73 times earnings, there is no question that it is still too expensive -- particularly when appraised on a price-to-cash-flow basis. Now that the hype is over, investors want to know two things. First, when is a right time to place a bet? And second, what guarantees are there that it can be sold at a higher price when it's ready to be sold?
This goes back to that all-important question -- what is social media worth? Once investors arrive at that answer, it should be followed with a system of applying the proper valuation to the stock.
There is no question that Facebook has all of the makings of a successful company -- one that can certainly grow into its valuation and produce the type of earnings to justify its IPO hype. However, to what extent? This is the part that Wall Street still has not figured out.
Disappointingly, investors wanted to re-live the pre-tech bubble IPO days where everything soared 50% on their first day of trading and valuation metrics were only for geeks -- while forgetting the operative word: "bubble." I think eventually the company will prove that it was more than just a fad, but it has to first prove that in addition to being a good idea, it has a better underlying business.
As it stands even with the company's popularity, it is still looking up to search giant Google
in the rankings among the most widely visited Web sites in the world. While Facebook comes in a close second, I am beginning to wonder what else does that ranking imply?
Facebook also lags Google in several other categories -- specifically in terms of business fundamentals. A recent report suggested that 15% of all Web surfing time was on social networking sites where Facebook clearly dominates. So although it is now second, there is reason to suspect that it won't be long before it takes over the top spot.
Reasons for Optimism
Its plummeting stock price notwithstanding, based on the company's growth trajectory there are plenty of reasons for investors to remain optimistic. Since being founded in 2004 as a niche project for college students to connect with each other, Facebook has grown today to a service with over 800 million active users.
Even more remarkable is how its demographic continues to adopt the service and adapt to new trends. The median age of a user has increased from 26 in May 2008 to 33. And as it stands today, almost 50% of the U.S. population is now Facebook users -- this according to an eMarketer survey.
Not only is the North American demographic growing but investors have to be pleased with how it continues to expand overseas where Germany, Russia as well as South Korea have seen year-over-year growth of 47%, 74% and 57%.
There are many lessons that continue to be learned from this IPO. Clearly there have been some mistakes, but the most egregious error was the "larger-than-life" persona sold by the media, the company and its underwriters. To put it plainly, the whole event was a circus that proved the tent was 100-times too big for the animals that were there to perform -- and on top of that the performance was unimpressive.
Be that as it may, as the stock remains above $30, I don't think I can afford it just yet. But as it continues to inch closer to the $25 level, I think I might just "like" it then.
Tickers in this article: FB
Latest news from section
Latest news from TheStreet